top of page

Buying Guide: Guitars

Writer's picture: Eugene SongEugene Song


We get a lot of questions here about how to pick and purchase guitars, especially from beginner students (or their caretakers). Buying your first guitar can be like a breakfast buffet: exciting at first, but overwhelming the longer you stare at it. So many brands, sizes, and ways to look cool holding them... Not to worry! We’re here to guide you through the noise and help you pick a guitar that’s just right for you (or your budding musician).


Step 1: Size

Guitars aren’t a one-size-fits-all deal. Just like softball bats or tennis rackets, it's important to choose the right size to ensure comfort while holding and playing the instrument. A 6-year-old trying to wrangle a full-size guitar would be like a toddler trying to swing an adult-sized 3 wood!


The age of the student is often a good proxy for finding a good size match. Here’s our quick guide:


  • Ages 5-8: Go for a 1/2-size (34") guitar. Small hands need small guitars.

  • Ages 8-12: Try a 3/4-size (36") guitar. It’s a step up but still manageable.

  • Ages 12 and up: Full-size (40") guitars are usually a safe bet. That said, smaller-bodied models might still be more comfortable for petite players (or anyone who prefers a lighter option).


Try before you buy if you can. Comfort is key, and no one wants to practice on a guitar that feels like wrestling an animal.


Step 2: Acoustic vs. Electric: The Great Debate

I've been asked a lot about whether I play electric or acoustic guitar. It's important to keep in mind that both types of guitars are tuned to the same notes, using the same fret system. So technically, a guitar player could play the same song on either type of guitar with the same chord and fingering patterns. The difference is primarily in the type of sounds or music you want to hear out of the instrument (think Hendrix vs. James Taylor).


As a beginner, though, there are a few important considerations:


  • Acoustic Guitars:

    • Great for beginners who want to dive into singer-songwriter vibes or classic strumming.

    • You have the option of steel or nylon strings. The latter can be much easier on beginners' fingertips.

    • No amp required—just you, your guitar, and your future fan club.

  • Electric Guitars:

    • Perfect for those dreaming of shredding solos and rocking out with power chords.

    • Easier on the fingers and often more comfortable to hold.

    • But you’ll need an amp and some extra gear to get started.

    • Can be more expensive


Our recommendation is that kids should start with an acoustic guitar with nylon strings. While it's true that electric guitar strings are often easier to press onto the fretboard, nylon strings are still more comfortable for beginner fingers. It's far easier to just pick up and play since there is no extra gear required, so there are fewer barriers to practicing.


We'd suggest that adults opt for steel-string acoustic guitars, unless they are particularly interested in playing classical or Spanish-style guitar music.


Step 3: Product Options

A solid starter guitar doesn’t have to cost a fortune, but going too cheap can backfire. Low-quality guitars often have tuning issues or are just plain hard to play—both major buzzkills for beginners.


(Note: Are you or your guitar player left-handed? If so, be sure to look for the left-handed versions of the below models)


Acoustic Guitars


Electric Guitars


Other Options

  • Used Guitars: You can often score a great used guitar for less. Just have someone knowledgeable inspect it first—you don’t want to inherit someone else’s problems.

  • Loog Guitars -- Loogs are great starter guitars for smaller children, under the age of 5. But if the child is older, we'd recommend one of the options above.

  • Ukelele -- Ukeleles are wonderful instruments, but are quite different than guitars. The tuning is different as is the general style of playing.


(Note: All prices listed are based on the price on the the date of publishing of this post)


Step 4: Don’t Forget the Accessories

No matter what kind of guitar you pick, there are a few must-haves to complete the package. (Note: Some of the above options come with some of the below accessories):

  • A tuner (clip-on or pedal—either works!)

  • A strap (even if you’re sitting, it’s handy for practice)

  • Picks (note that they come in different thickenesses, so some experimentation to find the right one will be helpful)

  • A gig bag or case (electric or acoustic)

  • For electrics: an amplifier and a cable


Good Luck!

Picking the right guitar is the first step on an amazing musical adventure. Whether you’re strumming campfire classics or plugging in to play power chords, the right instrument makes all the difference. If you’re still on the fence, reach out! We’re always happy to help you find your perfect match.

© 2024 by Green Room Music.
info@greenroommusic.com | ‪(914) 200-4577‬

bottom of page